Ice Cream Shop Failure Rate: Why They Fail & 5 Tips for Success

Starting an ice cream shop can be a pretty sweet venture, with relatively low overhead cost and high profit margin potential. In fact, net profit margins typically average between 12% and 30%!

However, the ice cream industry isn’t without its hurdles. For example, it’s highly competitive, with 83% of consumers purchasing ice cream at grocery stores, compared to just 30% at specialty shops.

From navigating seasonal revenue fluctuations to standing out in a crowded market, success requires careful planning and adaptability. Understanding the challenges — and how to overcome them — can make all the difference.

In this guide, we’ll explore the factors behind the average ice cream shop failure rate, common pitfalls to avoid, and strategies for long-term success. With the right tools and mindset, your shop can thrive in any environment. Let’s dig in!

Key takeaways

• Ice cream shops benefit from lower overhead costs and attractive profit margins, which may contribute to a lower failure rate than other types of restaurants.

• Success requires navigating seasonal revenue fluctuations, standing out in a competitive market, and adapting to economic shifts.

• Unique branding, premium ingredients, and memorable customer experiences are critical to standing out from competitors and fostering loyalty.

• Retaining happy, well-trained employees and creating a detailed budget with back-up plans are essential for long-term sustainability.

• Tools like POS systems that integrate online ordering, inventory management, and loyalty programs streamline operations and enhance customer engagement, helping shops thrive year-round.

What is the average ice cream shop failure rate?

According to restaurant packaging provider Limepack, 20% of ice cream shops fail within their first year, and 50% fail within their first five years.

While the company is based in the EU, this aligns closely with Owner’s estimate that 17% of restaurants fail within their first year. The National Restaurant Association, on the other hand, estimates the average restaurant failure rate is 30%.

It’s worth noting that ice cream shops generally have higher net profit margins and lower overhead costs compared to other types of restaurants. This is due to their smaller spaces, minimal equipment needs, and reduced staffing requirements. These factors could indicate that the average ice cream shop failure rate is even lower than the estimates above. 

However, these businesses also face unique challenges, such as seasonal fluctuations in revenue, which can put pressure on cash flow during off-peak months. Ultimately, ice cream shop failure rates vary significantly based on factors like:

• Regional differences: Seasonal demand and climate variations can affect year-round profitability.

• Shop type: Independent shops may face greater risks compared to franchise-owned locations with established brand recognition. Food trucks typically have even lower overhead and larger profit margins than traditional storefronts.

• Local competition: The number of nearby ice cream shops or dessert-focused businesses can impact customer traffic and sales.

4 reasons ice cream shops fail (and how to avoid them)

Running a successful ice cream shop requires a strong business strategy that can adapt to challenges and keep customers coming back, no matter the weather. Let’s explore some of the most common reasons ice cream shops fail — and how you can avoid them.

1. Not preparing for economic changes

Because sweet treats are more of a luxury than an essential item, ice cream shops are particularly vulnerable to economic downturns. For instance, the COVID-19 pandemic led to reduced foot traffic, supply chain issues, and unexpected closures.

To prepare for economic challenges, consider implementing these strategies:

• Create new revenue streams: Offer delivery, curbside pickup, and ice cream sundae kits for at-home enjoyment. This way, you’re not solely dependent on in-store traffic.

• Embrace technology: Use online ordering platforms, branded mobile apps, and email marketing to reach customers directly.

Example

Philadelphia-based Scoop Deville uses technology to their advantage and has several different revenue streams, including:

• In-store ice cream sales

• Delivery (ran by the shop)

• Third-party delivery (ie, Doordash)

• Gift ordering (ie, Confetti Pretzel Boxes, Brownie and Cookie Gift Boxes, etc.)

• Cake ordering

• Gift cards

• Merchandise

• Catering, private events, and fundraising

• Wholesale
  
  

2. Intense competition

With both large chains and boutique shops vying for market share, blending in is a recipe for failure in the ice cream industry. Additionally, competing solely on price can erode your margins and lead to a race to the bottom.

Ice cream shops without a unique concept struggle to attract repeat customers, as there’s little to set them apart from competitors. Standing out in a competitive market requires these key steps:

• Conduct market research: Identify your target audience and pinpoint gaps in your local market. Whether it’s offering niche flavors, dietary-friendly options, or a themed experience, find a way to stand out.

• Create memorable branding: Build a cohesive brand story that resonates with your audience. Your logo, store design, menu, and marketing should all reflect your unique concept and values.

• Customer experience: Focus on creating memorable interactions that build loyalty. Host events, offer seasonal flavors, and create loyalty programs to encourage repeat visits.

• Product differentiation: Use premium ingredients, offer exclusive flavors, and emphasize sustainability. 56% of consumers are willing to pay more for ice cream packaged in eco-friendly materials!

Example

Salt & Straw, an ice cream shop chain with locations in seven different states, is a perfect example of success through differentiation. Their shops stand out for several reasons, including:

• Unique flavors crafted in collaboration with award-winning chefs.

• Making their products with grass-fed, hormone-free dairy.

• A monthly menu series featuring limited-time flavors.

• Working with local makers, farmers, and chefs in each new location.

• Supporting social causes and charities.
  
  

3. Inadequate staff management

High employee turnover can throw your operations off balance, disrupt customer service, and tarnish your shop’s reputation. Inconsistent service leaves a lasting negative impression on customers, making it harder to build a loyal following.

To ensure effective staff management, focus on these approaches:

• Invest in staff training: Equip managers with leadership skills and provide employees with ongoing training to ensure consistent, high-quality service. A well-trained team delivers a better customer experience.

• Foster a positive culture: Motivate staff with flexible schedules, team outings, and performance-based incentives. Creating a supportive work environment reduces burnout and boosts retention.

• Ask for feedback: Hold regular feedback sessions to understand employee concerns and show them their opinions matter. Happy employees lead to happy customers!

Example

As Klavon’s Ice Cream Parlor in Pittsburgh was reopening after the pandemic restrictions were lifted, owner Jacob Hanchar had trouble hiring. Desperate to hire employees before the summer began, he raised the wages for open positions from the minimum wage of $6.25 an hour to $15 an hour. 

After receiving over 1,000 applications, he filled every position virtually overnight, and his experiment paid dividends. Hanchar said:

“From a top-line perspective, we have more people coming into our shop as a result of raising our wage because people want to support a business that’s taking care of their employees… Also, our costs are going down because of less turnover.”

4. Insufficient capital and budgeting

Underestimating the financial investment required to start and sustain an ice cream shop is one more common mistake. Startup costs can add up quickly, and unexpected expenses or seasonal revenue dips can leave you scrambling for cash.

To avoid these pitfalls, be sure to:

• Create a detailed budget: Outline all startup and ongoing costs, including a contingency fund for unexpected expenses. Don’t forget to factor in seasonal revenue fluctuations to ensure your business stays afloat year-round.

• Leverage data analytics: Monitor analytics to track sales trends, customer preferences, and peak times. Adjust inventory, staffing, and marketing based on this data to boost profits.

• Start small: Test your concept with a pop-up shop or food truck. This approach minimizes initial costs and allows you to refine your offerings before committing to a permanent location.

Example

MIchigan-based Milk & Froth began as an ice cream truck in Detroit before expanding to a brick-and-mortar location in 2021. The brand has always sold artisanal, dairy- and vegan-free ice cream made in small batches.

Four years after launching their first store, the business now operates locations across seven different cities in Michigan.

5 tips for improving your ice cream shop’s chance of success

To maximize your chances of success, you need to go beyond simply avoiding common pitfalls. Here are strategic approaches that can help your store thrive:

1. Streamline operations with technology: Use your POS system to manage inventory, access detailed sales and expenses reports, seamlessly integrate online ordering, and much more.

2. Invest in loyalty programs: Build a base of repeat customers by offering rewards, discounts, or exclusive access to new flavors.

3. Incorporate limited-time offers: Drive traffic with rotating flavors tied to seasons, holidays, or local events, like pumpkin spice in fall or peppermint in winter.

4. Optimize your online presence: Keep your website, Google Business account, and Yelp profile updated, respond to reviews, and engage with customers on social media. Share mouthwatering photos of your ice cream creations to attract more visitors.

5. Build community partnerships: Collaborate with local businesses or organizations for events, sponsorships, or catering opportunities to increase visibility and attract new customers.

Scoop up success 

Running a successful ice cream shop requires more than just serving delicious scoops — it’s about navigating challenges, standing out in a competitive market, and building strong customer loyalty. With lower overhead costs and attractive profit margins, ice cream shops have incredible potential, but success hinges on smart planning, adaptability, and leveraging the right tools.

Related Restaurant Operations Resources

• Restaurant Business Plan Template
• Bar Business Plan
• Food Truck Business Plan
• Caterer Business Plan
• Ice Cream Shop Business Plan
• Coffee Shop Business Plan
• Brewery Business Plan
  
• Cafe Business Plan
• Nightclub Business Plan
• Pizzeria Business Plan
• Bakery Business Plan
• Juice Bar Business Plan
• Small Restaurant Business Plan