A single catering order could introduce your food to dozens of people who might never have tried your restaurant. That makes catering a great way to bring in new regular customers, on top of bringing in extra sales.
To learn how people plan, order, and pay for catering, Toast surveyed 850 U.S. adults who ordered catering from a restaurant in the past year. Here is what they shared and how it can help you grow your catering business.
Catering insights
65% of surveyed guests say they consider themselves regulars at a restaurant after trying it through catering
91% of surveyed guests say they order catering directly from the restaurant, by phone, online, or in person
55% of surveyed guests say food quality matters most when choosing a caterer, compared with 14% who say price
65% of surveyed guests say they’ve had a problem with a catering order, most often wrong or missing items (20%)
35% of surveyed guests say discounts on large or repeat orders would most make them order again
94% of surveyed guests say they are likely to order restaurant catering for an event in the next three months
What the data suggests about catering trends
Every person surveyed ordered catering from a restaurant in the past 12 months. Here is what their responses mean for your restaurant.
65% of surveyed guests became regulars after trying a restaurant through catering
Catering puts your food in front of people who may never have walked through your door. 65% of surveyed guests say they’ve started dining at a restaurant regularly after first trying it through catering.

Treat every catering order like a first impression. Include a take-home menu, a QR code for your online menu, or a special coupon so everyone enjoying the food knows where to find you next time.
Catering demand is steady, and 27% of surveyed guests are ordering more
Among the guests surveyed that ordered catering in the last 12 months, 56% say they order catering a few times a year, and 24% order once a month or more. Compared with a year ago, 27% say they’re ordering catering more often, 64% about the same, and 9% less often.
Personal celebrations are the most common reason guests order catering. Birthdays and family celebrations are the most common catering occasion (32%), followed by holiday parties (24%), work meetings and office events (24%), and game days or casual get-togethers (12%).
This mix also shows up in who pays for the meal: 50% of surveyed guests pay out of pocket, 31% have their company or organization cover it, and 20% split the total with friends or coworkers.
Most catering orders serve 10 to 49 people and cost $100 to $499
The typical catering order from surveyed guests is mid-sized. 42% of surveyed guests say their typical order serves 10 to 24 people, and 29% say 25 to 49 people. Only 14% order for fewer than 10, and 15% order for 50 or more.
Spending follows suit. 37% of surveyed guests typically spend $250 to $499 on a single catering order, including tax, tip, and fees, and 32% spend $100 to $249. 24% spend $500 or more.
Looking at cost per person, 53% of surveyed guests spend $10 to $19 per head, while 40% spend $20 or more.

35% of catering orders are placed two days ahead or less
Catering is often a last-minute decision. 9% of surveyed guests usually order the same day, and 26% order one to two days ahead. Another 31% order three to six days ahead, while 34% plan one week or more in advance.

If your catering menu requires three or more days of advance notice, you might be missing out on a third of potential customers. Think about offering a streamlined menu built using ingredients your kitchen already prepares daily.
91% of surveyed guests order catering directly from the restaurant
Most people prefer to order directly. 43% of surveyed guests usually order catering by calling the restaurant, 28% place their order on the restaurant website, and 20% order in person. Only 5% use a dedicated catering site, and 4% use a delivery app.

People also tend to pick places they already trust. 38% choose a restaurant they already dine at, 23% rely on a recommendation from a friend or coworker, and 23% search online or read reviews. Only 11% search on catering or delivery apps, 3% ask AI tools like ChatGPT or Gemini, and 2% look on social media.
Convenience shapes how people order. 38% of surveyed guests chose their ordering method because it was easy to use or reorder from, while 23% said it was because they already knew and trusted the restaurant. 12% picked their method to avoid extra fees or lower the total cost.
Phone calls are still popular, but online ordering has plenty of room to grow. Adding a clear catering menu to your website gives customers a fast way to order without needing to pick up the phone.
Food quality matters most, and family-style trays are the favorite format
When choosing a restaurant for catering, 55% of surveyed guests say food quality matters most. Menu variety follows at 21%, and price at 14%. Only 6% put on-time, reliable service first, 3% dietary options, and 1% ease of ordering.
Family-style trays and platters are the clear favorite format, preferred by 58% of surveyed guests. 18% prefer build-your-own bars like tacos, salads or bowls, 15% prefer individually packaged meals or boxed lunches, 7% prefer appetizers or grazing boards, and 3% prefer plated meals served by staff.
Most surveyed guests want their food brought to them. 37% prefer delivery with drop-off, 30% delivery with setup, and 28% pickup. Only 5% prefer full service with staff on site.
Nearly half (47%) of surveyed guests usually plan for at least one dietary need. Food allergies are the most common (23%), followed by vegetarian or vegan (10%), gluten-free (10%), and halal or kosher (5%). Label allergens clearly on every tray and offer at least one vegetarian option in your standard packages.
65% of surveyed guests have had a problem with a catering order
Only 35% of surveyed guests say they haven’t had a problem with a restaurant catering order. Wrong or missing items are the most common issue (20%), followed by not enough food (12%), food that arrived cold or was poor quality (11%), and late delivery or pickup not ready (10%). Unexpected fees or charges (6%) and difficulty placing or changing an order (5%) round out the list.
Most of these issues can be avoided in the kitchen. Double-check every order against the receipt before sending it out, measure portions carefully based on group size, and include basic setup or serving tips with the food.
Discounts on large or repeat orders would bring the most guests back
When asked what would most make them order catering from a restaurant again, 35% of surveyed guests chose discounts for large or repeat orders. 21% chose easy online ordering with instant pricing, 20% chose loyalty rewards on catering orders, and 16% chose flexible menu customization. 7% want a dedicated contact at the restaurant.
Offering discounts on large orders or loyalty rewards for catering can turn a one-time order into repeat business, especially for offices that order regularly.
94% of surveyed guests plan to order catering this holiday season
The next three months are a major opportunity. 54% of surveyed guests are very likely to order restaurant catering for an event in the next three months, and 40% are somewhat likely. Only 6% are not likely.
Since nearly a quarter of surveyed guests say holiday parties are their most common catering occasion, now is the perfect time to share your holiday menu, set clear order deadlines, and promote your offerings to your current customers.
Turn catering into a reliable source of new business
Catering exposes your food to new people, and many of them could become regular customers. Make ordering easy with clear pricing on your website, offer a quick-turnaround menu for last-minute orders, and provide repeat-customer discounts. Most importantly, ensure every order is accurate, on time, and includes an invitation to visit your restaurant in person.
Methodology
Toast conducted a blind survey of 850 U.S. adults ages 18 and older who ordered catering from a restaurant in the past 12 months. The survey was completed on October 30, 2026. Participants were not informed that Toast conducted the study. Based on standard statistical calculations with a 95% confidence level, the margin of error is +/- 3–5% on average.


