Skip to main content

Toast vs Square: Which POS is Right for Canadian Restaurants?

Looking at Toast vs Square POS in Canada? Let’s take a closer look at their pricing, features, scalability, and fit for your specific type of restaurant.

Canada Toast Vs Square

Toast vs Square Canada at a Glance

Toast vs. Square Canada on

Toast

Square

Pricing approach

Flat-fee pricing with core restaurant features — including check splitting and course management — included across plans. No need to upgrade to unlock day-to-day tools.

Restaurants can start for free at $0/month CAD. Key features like course management, check splitting, and advanced reporting are gated behind the Plus Plan at $60/month CAD per location, or Premium.‡

Support

Every Toast plan includes 24/7 support by phone, email, or chat.

Free plan phone support is available Monday to Friday, 9 am–9pm EST.

24/7 phone support requires Square for Restaurants Plus at $60/month CAD per location, or a Square Register or Terminal subscription.‡

Setup and implementation

Toast offers a range of onboarding and implementation services, from self-service to premium on-site installation, depending on your business needs and complexity.  

Square is designed for self onboarding — setup is account-guided. One-on-one implementation services are available on Plus ($60/month CAD per location) and Premium plans.‡

Hardware

Toast was built to support restaurants, with hardware engineered for food service environments.

Toast Flex 3 is designed for spill and splash resistance, and has been tested to withstand temperatures up to 50°C.

Square was founded to support small businesses in general. Much of Square’s hardware is designed to work across industries.





Square Stand and Square Kiosk are iPad-dependent — iPads do not carry an IP rating for water or dust. (Note: Customer’s must supply their own IPad**)

Reservation management

Native first-party reservations and table management — waitlist, online reservations, server rotation, and Reserve with Google, all integrated directly with Toast POS.

No native reservations product. Reservation functionality requires a third-party integration — such as OpenTable^ (paid subscription required) — available on Square for Restaurants Plus only.

Canadian payments

Accepts Interac chip and tap — essential for Canadian operators as debit is one of the most common ways guests pay.

Also accepts Interac chip and tap. 

Restaurant workflow capabilities

Toast’s restaurant workflows were designed to handle the complexities of table service, kitchen workflows, and large menus.

May be a practical fit for counter-service and lower-complexity food concepts.



Scalability

Centralised menu management, performance tracking across locations, and advanced real-time reporting across all plans. Built for restaurants growing from one location to many.



Multi-location management included across plans, with menu management and basic reporting available at the Free tier. Advanced features such as course management and live sales reporting require Plus at $60/month CAD per location.‡

Toast vs Square for Canadian Restaurants: Which POS is Right for Your Business?

Square's free tier is a genuine starting point — for a new counter-service spot in Calgary or a solo operator testing the waters, $0/month CAD is hard to argue with.

The fuller picture is worth understanding before you commit.

On Square's Free plan, course management, bill splitting, and advanced reporting aren't included — those require Square for Restaurant Plus at $60/month CAD per location. If your restaurant depends on those tools day-to-day, the plan you actually end up running on may cost more than the headline rate suggests.‡

Toast's pricing is flat-fee and includes core restaurant functionality across its plans. In other words, you may be less likely to find yourself upgrading mid-operation to access tools you already need.


It's also worth tallying the full stack. If running on Square means adding a separate reservations tool, a third-party loyalty app, and a standalone online ordering platform, you may want to compare the all-in cost of each setup — not just the POS subscription.

Restaurant Workflow Depth

Toast is built around the way restaurants actually work — table management connected directly to your POS, kitchen display systems that keep front-of-house and back-of-house in sync, tableside ordering via handhelds, and modifier capabilities for complex menus.

On the reservations side, Square has no native product. Canadian operators who need reservations functionality need to integrate with a third-party platform — such as OpenTable (paid subscription required) — available on Square for Restaurants Plus only.

Toast Tables brings reservations, waitlist, and table management together in one place, with no cover fees, connected directly to your POS. Toast customers in the US with Toast Tables saw a 57% lift in Toast Loyalty sign-ups.*

*Based on Toast internal data comparing loyalty sign-ups in Q2 2025 vs Q2 2024. Individual results will vary.

When something goes wrong in the midst of a busy shift, response time matters.

In Canada, Toast includes 24/7 chat support and phone support Mon–Fri, 9am–10pm EST (Extended availability coming 2027).

With Square, phone support on the Free plan runs Monday to Friday, 9am–9pm PT. Reaching someone by phone outside those hours requires Square for Restaurants Plus at $60/month CAD per location.*

Square is built for fast setup. If you need to be taking payments this week with minimal configuration, that's what it's designed for. And, for simpler food concepts in Canada, that could be a good fit.

Toast runs on its own dedicated network infrastructure, which is what enables offline mode to keep your POS running if your internet drops mid-service. Setup can be accelerated by a dedicated Onboarding Consultant — on-site or remote depending on your package — who guides your restaurant through configuration, menu build, and go-live.

Implementation is a paid component of your Toast setup, with costs varying by hardware package and installation needs.

The question worth sitting with: What does switching POS systems mid-operation actually cost? Retraining your team, rebuilding your menu, reconnecting your tools. Let’s say you’re a sit-down restaurant in Toronto, or a multi-location concept expanding to a second location in Vancouver. Building that into your decision now — rather than after you've outgrown your first system — is worth the time.

Which POS Fits Your Restaurant?

Toast is designed for restaurants that are operating with some degree of complexity, or that can see themselves getting there. The initial setup process can be more involved than Square's, but it could serve your restaurant
better in the long haul.

Square CA may be worth considering if you're…

Square can work well for these formats. Operators who find they need more as their business grows — reservations, advanced reporting, complex kitchen workflows — will need to upgrade or connect third-party tools. Switching POS systems mid-operation can take time and disrupt your team, so it's worth thinking through your longer-term needs now.

  • Opening a café, food truck, or counter-service spot with a straightforward menu and want to get started quickly without upfront implementation costs.

  • Running a simpler operation where course management, reservations, and advanced reporting aren't day-to-day requirements. (Or, you're comfortable adding those via third-party integrations on a Plus plan.)

  • Prioritizing low startup cost above all else. Square's Free plan includes multi-location management and basic order tools with no monthly fee.

Toast may be a good fit if you're…
  • Running a full-service restaurant, bar, or café with table service and a more complex operation.

  • Managing — or thinking about opening — multiple locations across Canada, with centralized menu management and reporting across sites.

  • Looking for reservations, waitlist, and table management connected directly to your POS, with no cover fees and no third-party subscription required.

  • Prioritising support access: 24/7 phone, email, and chat on every software plan, from day one.

  • Building a restaurant where front-of-house, back-of-house, and back-office need to stay in sync with payments, kitchen display systems, in-depth reporting, and more all on one platform.

Frequently Asked Questions: Toast vs Square for Canadian Restaurants

The pricing structures for Toast and Square in Canada are different. Square offers a Free tier and a Plus plan at $60/month CAD per location. Toast pricing in Canada is quote-based and varies depending on your individual needs.

With Square, advanced features like course management, bill splitting, and in-depth reporting require Plus. Reservations require a third-party integration — such as OpenTable — on Plus only. If you'd be adding those tools on top of a Square subscription, the all-in cost looks different than the starting price suggests.

The Bottom Line

If your hospitality business needs reliable operations, a broader restaurant-specific feature set, and support available every day from the moment you go live — Toast is designed for that.

Square's free tier makes it easy to get started, but as your operation grows, so does the cost and complexity of the integrations you'll need to keep up. Toast gives you an all-inclusive platform built for restaurants from day one — so you're not outgrowing your tools right when things start to take off.

The bottom Line